GIRL TALK AND FAIR USE
When it comes to Girl Talk and copyright laws, the
conversation gets cloudy and confusing. The mash up connoisseur is known for
sampling small portions of big songs and layering them altogether into one huge
remix. The samples he uses and the way he places them together transforms them
into something that is original and unique. So we ask the following questions:
Is he breaking copyright laws or is his work protected under the exceptions of
fair use?
Girl Talk’s Greg Gillis argues that he has transformed the
copyrighted materials enough for it to be protected under fair use. It seems as
if his argument would fall under the third portion of the fair use criteria, which
states the following: the amount and
substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a
whole. While Girl Talk is using pieces of copyrighted material, his argument of
fair use is a strong one. When listening to his music, you do recognize samples
from other songs, but his work is so unique that you get lost in the originality
of it.
If Girl Talk had
decided to go through and get the licenses of all the samples he used in his
albums, it would take him endless hours to do so and cost him thousands and
thousands of dollars. More than likely, he would not even be able to get
through the entire process and ultimately would not be able to make his albums
a reality.
To date, no one has
sued Girl Talk for copyright infringement. His case for fair use is obviously working,
and until otherwise contradicted, it seems he should continue to stand with his
case.
I like when you said "When listening to his music, you do recognize samples from other songs, but his work is so unique that you get lost in the originality of it." and I completely agree with that statement.
ReplyDeleteGirl Talk's music is fun, expressive, innovative, and creative. He is obviously talented and puts a great deal of thought and effort into the songs he makes. Its sad to think that we live in a world so concerned with legal technicalities that he could possibly be robbed of his ability to create his art. So many people love his music and I think we should encourage people to be innovative and expressive without the fear of being prosecuted.
But anyways, good post!